Navigating Job Rejection: How Recruiters Can Handle Tough Conversations with Compassion
In recruitment, one of the most challenging aspects of the job is delivering news of rejection to candidates. While it may be tempting to delay these difficult conversations, addressing them head-on is crucial for maintaining professionalism and fostering relationships. Often, we are not trained on how to handle these discussions on the job, and sadly, some recruiters avoid them altogether. But by facing them directly, and practicing a few basic principles such as compassion, empathy, and transparency, you can better navigate these difficult conversations.
Why to Have the Hard Conversation
- Respecting the Candidate’s Time and Effort
Candidates invest significant time and effort into pursuing job opportunities. They update their resumes, craft personalized cover letters, attend interviews, and some may even travel (sometimes at their own expense) for an interview in a different state or city. Acknowledging this investment by providing timely and respectful feedback demonstrates that you value their commitment and respect their efforts.
- Maintaining Professionalism
Delivering rejection news is a fundamental aspect of the recruitment process. Balancing professionalism with empathy and care demonstrates respect for the candidate as a human being rather than just a potential placement. It reinforces the recruiter’s integrity and commitment to transparent communication, which is vital in building trust.
- Preserving the Candidate Relationship
A well-managed rejection can leave a positive impression, even if the outcome isn’t what the candidate hoped for. By providing constructive feedback and maintaining a respectful tone, recruiters can ensure that candidates remain open to future opportunities with the organization. They may not have gotten this job, but there will always be another, and the next one may be a perfect fit. By prioritizing the relationship with candidates, you proactively build a talent pool of engaged and informed talent who may be suitable for future roles.
How to Have the Hard Conversation
- Prepare Thoroughly
Before initiating the conversation, gather all necessary information. Understand the reasons behind the rejection and be ready to provide specific, constructive feedback. This means contacting the client, sales rep, or hiring manager to inquire about why exactly the candidate was rejected. This preparation ensures that the conversation is informative and not just simply bad news, helping the candidate know where they stand. Don’t use preparing as an excuse for delay.
- Choose the Right Medium
While email rejections are common, they lack the empathic touch that a phone call or face-to-face conversation can offer. Think about it: if you were rejected from a job, wouldn’t you want something a bit more personalized? So, whenever possible, opt for a virtual meeting, or at the very least a phone call. This allows for an open discussion, rather than struggling to phrase a difficult email. This not only shows respect but also helps preserve (and even enhance) the candidate’s relationship.
- Be Direct but Compassionate
Start the conversation by clearly stating the outcome. Avoid ambiguous language that might confuse the candidate. People often like people that are direct, but remember to balance this directness with sensitivity. Many of us have experienced getting rejected from a job in the past, so use this personal experience to your advantage. Be sure to also acknowledge the candidate’s efforts and express gratitude for their interest in the role.
- Provide Constructive Feedback
Feedback is crucial for candidates to improve and succeed in future applications. Again, this may mean you have to proactively solicit feedback from the hiring managers. Offer specific insights into why they were not selected and, if possible, suggest areas for improvement. Frame feedback positively, focusing on how they can leverage their strengths and address any weaknesses.
Sometimes, however, hiring managers don’t provide concrete (or any) feedback. If this happens, then it’s incumbent on you as the recruiter to strategize with the candidates on how to approach the next opportunity.
- Encourage Future Engagement
End the conversation on a positive note by encouraging the candidate to stay in touch. Inform them about other potential opportunities within the organization or the industry that might be a good fit. Let them know that you, as the recruiter, are in their court. This approach reinforces that their application was valued and keeps the door open for future interactions.
Having the hard conversation with candidates about job rejections is, unfortunately, a critical part of the recruitment process. But by employing the strategies above, you can navigate this discussion more easily. At Planet Forward, we emphasize the importance of handling the hard conversations with professionalism, empathy, and clarity. Just as these difficult conversations are essential, so is building and maintaining relationships
Looking for your next role? Check out our opportunities today.
Photo Credit: Canva